Buy used:
$5.56
FREE delivery Monday, May 20. Details
Or fastest delivery May 14 - 17. Details
Used: Acceptable | Details
Condition: Used: Acceptable
Comment: This is a used book. It may contain highlighting/underlining and/or the book may show heavier signs of wear . It may also be ex-library or without dustjacket.
Access codes and supplements are not guaranteed with used items.
Kindle app logo image

Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.

Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.

Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.

QR code to download the Kindle App

Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.

If Grace is True: Why God Will Save Every Person Paperback – November 23, 2004

4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars 328 ratings

There is a newer edition of this item:

Why Everyone Will Be in Heaven

Two pastors present their controversial belief in eternal salvation for all through God′s perfect grace. Long disturbed by the Church′s struggle between offering both love and rejection, they discover what God wants from us and for us: grace for everyone.

Read more Read less

The Amazon Book Review
The Amazon Book Review
Book recommendations, author interviews, editors' picks, and more. Read it now.

Editorial Reviews

Review

“[A] stirring manifesto on the central role of universalism in Christianity ...” (Publishers Weekly)

“Gulley and Mulholland stick to their guns as they tell their stories...with compassion, hope, kindness, and grace.” (Booklist)

“Gulley and Mulholland have extended and deepened the meaning of God’s grace in decidedly thoughtful and lovely ways.” (Arkansas Democrat Gazette)

“[T]his loving little book . . . is easily read and understood, a thought-provoker for any Disciple.” (DisciplesWorld)

“Gulley and Mulholland . . . have honestly faced the church’s traditional doctrines of salvation and eternal justice.” (Christianity Today)

“An easy read full of interesting stories and attractive assertions.” (Dallas News)

“One of the most helpful books on this subject to emerge in years.” (Crosswalk.com)

“The authors celebrate God’s extravagant grace in ways that remind us of the amazing thing we often sing it is.” (Ethicsdaily.com)

About the Author

Philip Gulley is a Quaker minister, writer, husband, and father. He is the bestselling author of Front Porch Tales, the acclaimed Harmony series, and is coauthor of If Grace Is True and If God Is Love. Gulley lives with his wife and two sons in Indiana, and is a frequent speaker at churches, colleges, and retreat centers across the country.



James Mulholland, author of Praying Like Jesus, is a theologian with ecumenical experience in the American Baptist, United Methodist, and Quaker denominations. He lives in Indianapolis, where he is active in neighborhood development.

Product details

  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ HarperOne; Reprint edition (November 23, 2004)
  • Language ‏ : ‎ English
  • Paperback ‏ : ‎ 256 pages
  • ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 0062517058
  • ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0062517050
  • Item Weight ‏ : ‎ 6.4 ounces
  • Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 5.5 x 0.75 x 8 inches
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars 328 ratings

About the author

Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.
Philip Gulley
Brief content visible, double tap to read full content.
Full content visible, double tap to read brief content.

Philip Gulley has become the voice of small town American life. Gulley is a Quaker pastor, writer, and speaker from Danville, Indiana. He has written 21 books, including the "Harmony" series recounting life in the eccentric Quaker community of Harmony, Indiana and the the "Hope" series which continues the exploits of Sam Gardner, first introduced in the "Harmony" series.

Gulley also authored the best-selling "Porch Talk" essay series. Gulley’s memoir, "I Love You, Miss Huddleston" was a finalist for the Thurber Prize for American Humor. In addition, Gulley, with co-author James Mulholland, shared their progressive spirituality in the books "If Grace Is True" and "If God Is Love,"" followed by Gulley’s books "If the Church Were Christian," "The Evolution of Faith," and "Living the Quaker Way."

Gulley's 22nd book entitled "Unlearning God: How Unbelieving Helped Me Believe" will be released on September 25, 2018.

"An illuminating spiritual memoir from America’s favorite Quaker storyteller shows how beliefs learned early must often be unlearned so that more helpful and enduring understandings can thrive."

You may read Philip Gulley’s essays in every issue of INDIANAPOLIS MONTHLY and THE SATURDAY EVENING POST. His weekly messages and upcoming speaking appearances are posted on his GraceTalks website at www.philipgulley.com

Customer reviews

4.6 out of 5 stars
4.6 out of 5
328 global ratings

Top reviews from the United States

Reviewed in the United States on September 28, 2007
I have already come to a point in my life where I dismissed tired church doctrine of manmade origins such as the trinity, blood sacrifice, once saved always saved, eternal damnation, virgin birth and all other such paganism repackaged as "Christianity". I no longer celebrate Christmas and Easter. I have been ridiculed by family and my old pastor and dismissed by friends but I have stuck to my guns. Having an open mind while reading this book was EASY for me. But for those of you still holding on to the blended religion of Christianity and paganism, which comprises most if not all denominations today-you will have a hard time accepting the ideas presented in this book.

I had already deduced a long time ago that my own experience with God was far more important than reading a book by someone who has translated the Dead Sea Scrolls backwards and forwards or someone who has rigidly and scholastically combed over the Scriptures with a fine tooth comb and can be considered an "expert" on the word of God. But are those people more of an expert than God himself? Can they give you forgiveness in your darkest hour? Will they stand face to face with you when your life is over? I already know that reading the word of God, or reading interpretations of this verse or that verse- is in addition to my personal walk with God-and does not replace it or even come close.

If you walk away with one thing from this book let it be the belief that God is not found in the Scriptures alone, nor is he found in a church pulpit or pew, nor is he found in a book. He talks to you when you listen, he walks with you when you invite him and he hears you when you call out to him, even if it is in just your darkest hour. He never abandons you. If you have ever called out to God in your darkest hour of pain and self loathing, after you had done something so hideous and despicable or someone has done similar to you, and felt him embrace your very soul and scoop you up in his arms and take over the burden of your pain and help you to move forward-then you know that of which I speak and you ought to know those moments shape your faith more than any translation of the bible, any single verse, any sermon, any doctrine or any book chalk full of so called exegesis.

Who are we to limit his love for ALL humanity? Who are we to dictate to him who he will save? Who are we to demand or even suggest that some of his own children suffer eternal damnation? Would you allow someone to tell you how to punish your child? Would you allow someone to tell you to murder your own child and leave them to suffer in a firey pit of hell for all eternity?

I find it increasingly arrogant that so many so called Christians think they can speak for God day in and day out and use Scripture to support this behavior. I really don't care how many verses in the bible contradict eachother and how many support your view or the author's view or a combination of both. I'm tired of the verse gymnastics so many Christians feel compelled to thrust at you everytime you have a differing theological opinion from them. All that time arguing and bickering and shoving your nose in some self righteous book put together through "scholarly exegesis" would be better spent in quiet reflection with God and "listening" to Him and loving him with all your heart as a child would-with an open mind, open heart and no preconceived notions and hang ups and personal biblical translations. God is not the bible and the bible is not God.

In summation this book is an excellent reminder to those of us that cherish our personal experience of God in our lives more than we do alleged biblical inerrancy or the supposed divinity of Christ, fear of hell or even the enticing though that our enemies will suffer one day. It is a reminder that only God has the power to forgive and give his grace and nothing we can do will ever cause us to lose that grace. Our relationship with God is one of mutual and unconditional love, not based on fear of eternal damnation or rejection. True obedience to God and faithfullness to him is born of the love you feel from him, not from the threat of a buring fire pit and eternal suffering. God does not coerce you to come to him, but once you come out of love you are less likely to stray than one who comes from fear of the unknown. We no longer fear God and because of that we can open our hearts more deeply to him and accept his grace, even if we have trouble reconciling it with how evil the world is today. Enjoy the book for what it is-an affirmation of God's limitless love, forgiveness and grace. Like the author's say, you will not be punished for overestimating God's love!
9 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on October 28, 2007
I believe that the original word of God is inspired (i.e. the Hebrew and Greek) - but I now believe that the translations of the bible are of the flesh and some are more "flesh" than others. It took me 20 years to figure this out though.

Back when I believed the King James was "THE" translation I was a young dumb Christian and kind of liked the idea that "spiritual losers" would burn in "hell". I was smart and read the bible, why should cult members and losers get into heaven anyway? They were self made men so to speak - they brought it on themselves I'd reason.

Then as I grew older problems crept into my theology by the truckload. I will say this - I wanted to know "the truth". So I was and am always willing to revise my beliefs as I learn and mature. Being a computer programmer I started dabbling in making my own versions of the bible (with software of course). And one program I wrote was to make my own concordance. So I mapped out every Greek and Hebrew word to every English word in the King James bible (back then that was the version you could get in ASCII) and lo and behold the King James translated many different Greek and Hebrew words into the same English words! And many of those words weren't even related. Hell was a good example but there are many others. (look up Gehenna, Hades, and Tarturus).

Then I learned about something called the law of Jubilee which means that at some point Jesus (our Kinsmen redeemer) will redeem all his near relatives and buy them back from the devil. That's why Jesus became a man. So at some point in time everything Adam lost (us) comes back to God (See Creations Jubilee by Stephen Jones). Another fun trick I taught my family was whenever you meet a hell fire preacher ask them about the law of Jubilee. No one who believes in an eternal hell will ever know about the law of Jubilee. They CAN'T! You're tank can only be full of love or hate. Not both. My wife and daughter went to a street fair last week. My daughter is twelve and she saw a hell fire preacher with the megaphone haranguing the people at the fair. My daughter went up to him and asked him about the law of Jubilee. The people who took her aren't Christian and told her not to go. They were afraid. Very afraid. But she knew where he was coming from. He had no clue about the law of Jubilee. then my daughter told him about it. I understand he actually "listened" to her. Conversion through fear of Hell is just fire insurance. God wants a loving relationship with us. "God is love" is a common theme in the bible. God is holy is where the "refiners fire" comes in. If you mix love and fire you get a purified human race EVENTUALLY! And that's what I believe the bible teaches. Then ALL the verses in the bible Harmonize. Try that experiment though. Ask any hell fire preacher you meet about the law of Jubilee (you should learn it yourself of course) and they'll say the Jubilee? Not really. Because I've never heard a sermon about this yet in 20 years. Then again I've never seen a blind person healed either or a whithered arm restored either.

Eternal Hell comes from lame translations of the bible. Anyone who puts their trust in a translation of the bible will run into trouble. It's no different than a Jew trusting the Talmud or a Catholic trusting the Catechism, or a Jehovoah's Witness trusting the New World Translation. If you don't read Hebrew and Greek (which I don't) get a good Interlinear bible and show yourself well approved unto God (2 Ti 2:15). You can only blame the powers that be at your church for so long. Eventually you need to take responsibility for your own spiritual growth.

Hellfire teaching depends on having certain translations of the bible to support your views (the King James being the main target). But redemption of all mankind by a kinsmen redeemer is in the law in Lev 25 and it's really simple. Rich relatives must buy back poor relatives from bondage. That's why Jesus is called a redeemer. And what's more it's not even by choice of either relative. The rich relative MUST do it. So there's really not much freewill involved for either party. Ask Paul. A strange thing happened to him on the way to Damascus. Jesus didn't say "Paul, by your own freewill would you like to be my apostle to the Gentiles..." Jesus said, "Guess what Paul you've been fighting me and now you're my apostle to the gentiles. You'll be blind for 3 days then you'll get to work for me. Have a nice day." So Jesus just needs to repeat this process a few billion times and voila! I'm being facetious but you get the point. The Greek word Helkuo used in John 6:44 means that God will "drag" us all to himself like Paul. And like a fish on a line you can put up a fight but the fisherman is Christ and you won't get away.

Also 1 Timothy 4:10 where it says that God will save ALL men ESPECIALLY those that believe. How could that be true? Hell will be empty then! No!!!!

Seriously -- this book's author went through the same cognitive dissonance that I had. God is love but he roasts the spiritually retarded eternally. Or God is "Just" so for 100 years of sin he'll repay you with an ETERNITY of damnation in a burning fire. How is that fair anyway?

It doesn't add up. I told my pastor that I thought all mankind will be saved EVENTUALLY! And now he thinks I said that all men go to heaven as soon as they die no matter what. That's not it though. The key word is Eventually. We have various judgments and resurrections going on and the Feast of Tabernacles is all about restoring the knowledge of God's word. That feast will come during the millennium or feast era. It's not here yet that's why there's such much spiritual darkness and tradition still taught.

The only thing in the book that I didn't agree with was where the author doesn't think that God will injure people then heal them. Because then he would be like a parent with Munchausen's syndrome. I didn't agree because I think there is a Godly purpose to the suffering God inflicts unlike the Munchausen's parent. The Author uses the example of the Jews asking whose sin caused the blind man to be blind. Then Jesus says it's for the glory of God. The author says God doesn't just injure to heal to get credit for healing like a Munchausen's parent. I understand (from the scriptures) that God's "refining fire" is suffering. And he uses tribulation to "burn off" our flesh nature. So the suffering, which God allows (or is responsible for), is, in the long run, to bring Glory to God through a mankind with a Godly character. That's why the Kingdom has 12 gates made of 1 giant pearl each. The pearls are symbolic of suffering because they are produced in an ugly shell and over a lifetime produce something beautiful and precious inside. So the "pearly gates" represent entrance into God's Kingdom through a lifetime of quiet suffering under water. So there is a purpose to God's inflicting wounds on us (or at least allowing them be afflicted) and it's not for God to get attention when he heals us but to produce Godly character in us.

But the spiritual metamorphosis this Author goes through in this book from spiritual pride and arrogance to that of Godly love flowing through him into world will happen to all Christians eventually as they leave spiritual infancy and move into spiritual maturity.

Awesome book!
17 people found this helpful
Report
Reviewed in the United States on April 1, 2024
Gulley is aways thought provoking. This one makes you think!
Reviewed in the United States on February 1, 2004
Writing for the general reader, the authors argue that the God of love is incompatible with the doctrine of eternal damnation. Salvation, they argue, is a transformation of the soul, being liberated from self-absorption, which has little to do with embracing any kind of orthodoxy, a Nicene creed, or some canned mantra. While I'm not sure where I stand on the issue of the afterlife, I found the book helpful in showing that biblical interpretation is a sort of Rorschach test. The God we pull out of the Bible often reflects our own biases and temperaments. For example, the authors say that the more mature they become, the more they see the complexities of human behavior, the more they replace their anger with love, the less they can believe in eternal damnation. Thus it is that the God that grows inside their hearts contradicts the notion of eternal perdition. As a result, they have evolved their interpretation of the Bible to exclude the idea of an eternal concentration camp for nonbelievers. They use several Bible passages to support their views and argue that not all scripture is equal. Scripture that defines grace, they assert, has more weight than scripture that defines God as a wrath-hungry Father displeased with his children. If I had to fault the book, the authors are too inclined to pick and choose from the Bible to come up with the God of their experience. As a result, the God of the Bible seems a bit sugar-coated and almost seems like wishful thinking on their part. On the other hand, I do appreciate a theology that rejects the idea of eternal damnation, which seems just as extreme, at the opposite pole, as does the candy-coated version of God.
16 people found this helpful
Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
Roy Abrahamian
5.0 out of 5 stars Excelente livro.
Reviewed in Brazil on October 10, 2016
Recomendo este livro a todos aqueles que desejam compreender a graça de Deus de uma maneira mais profunda e pregar um evangelho mais autêntico, que não exclua ninguém da salvação.
Russell J. Weston
5.0 out of 5 stars Will Jesus actually succeed in achieving his Father's will? Most christians don't believe so.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on April 6, 2015
In my experience, the vast majority - 99% plus - of Christians who reject the possibility that God may not only desire all people to be healed and reconciled to Him, but is actually destined to achieve His divine will, have spent little or no effort in exploring it as a possibility. If fact, many find this idea far more obnoxious & react more violently to it, than questions about Jesus Christ's virgin birth or divinity.

If one is going to proclaim a loving God that will one day condemn millions or billions of souls to destruction or eternal, never-ceasing torment for not loving Him or accepting Jesus as their own personal saviour, then one had better sure as hell make sure that one has fully examined the biblical case presented by those who proclaim that when Jesus said,"If I be lifted up from the earth, I will draw all men unto Me", he actually meant ALL.

This book does not claim to be the definitive theological "proof" of universal restoration. For a more thorough "theological" approach, one should also read "The Inescapable Love of God" by Thomas Talbott, amongst others, as well as familiarise yourself with the resources available at tentmaker dot org.

More and more christians are expressing an increasing sense of dis-ease & cognitive dissonance around the concept of a supposedly loving Father God condemning so many of his children - who inherited a flawed nature, not of their making - to hell. For anyone wanting to give the teaching of "universal restoration" a fair and intelligent hearing, this book has much to offer, as part of a wider exploration of the gospel of Grace.
4 people found this helpful
Report
Jean Wyatt
3.0 out of 5 stars If Grace is True: Why God will save every person
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on August 29, 2011
This book is easy to read, and heart warming.
It is interesting that it is co-authored by two pastors, and is written from a pastoral viewpoint.
I fully agree with the authors that GOD IS LOVE; that He loves every person he has created, and that it is His purpose to save every individual.
I was interested in the authors' testimony about how they moved from a fundamentalist Christian point of view, with a strong belief in hell to a position where they believe that God will certainly save every single person.
I wish I could agree with them, but I cannot fully endorse their position for three reasons:
1/ They jettison much of scripture
2/ They do not believe that Jesus was divine, nor that the crucifixion was part of God's plan
3/ Though I believe that God longs to save everybody, and that it is His will to do so, and that God will continue to reach out to people beyond the grave, I also believe that it may perhaps be possible to contine to reject God's love for ever.
3 people found this helpful
Report